2006 Season
Millspaugh put together a solid sophomore campaign as the Designated Hitter for the Mastodons. Millspaugh hit a robust .340 with nine doubles and 25 RBI. He is expected to see plenty of time at 1st base this year with the departure of Caleb Smith. Had a season-high four hits vs. Chicago State on 4/16. Drove in a season-high four runs vs. Valparaiso on 3/8. Scored twice in a game on four occasions (3/3 vs. Villanova, 3/9 vs. Mount Saint Mary's, 4/28 vs. Grace, and 5/7 vs. Evansville).

2005 Season
Millspaugh played well in limited action in 2005. Handy with the stick, Millspaugh hit at an oustanding .394 clip with four doubles and 8 RBI. Had a season-high four hits and three RBI against Taylor University on April 11. Doubled twice against Tri-State on April 18. Stole his lone base of the season against UW-Milwaukee on May 18.

High School
The infielder was first team All-State (2A), a member of the North/South All-Star team, and first team All-County as well as being selected Peru Chronicle-Tribune Player of the year. Millspaugh is also the career home run record holder at Oak Hill High School.